Banana Black Leaf Streak Disease in Hawaii -
Scot C. Nelson
Note: this is an unpublished draft of some relevant information about banana black leaf streak disease in Hawaii and its integrated management. It is intended for use by banana farmers and crop advisors. The article is based largely on the author's experience with banana cultivation in Hawaii. Any questions or comments about this article should be directed to Dr. Scot C. Nelson (snelson@hawaii.edu).
1. Introduction
2. Disease occurrence and significance in Hawaii
3. Symptoms
4. Causal organism: biology and life cycle
5. Disease cycle and epidemiology
a. Cultural management practices
b. Plant nutrition, crop logging and fertilizers
c. Chemical management and fungicides registered for use in Hawaii
7. Scouting and disease record keeping
9. Managing and preventing the development of fungicide resistance
Black leaf streak, also known as Black Sigatoka, was first recorded in 1964 from Fiji. This fungal disease of banana has since spread to most of the banana growing regions of the world and is regarded as one of the most important constraints on banana production worldwide. The disease is particularly important where growers cultivate monocrops of banana and cannot afford to use chemical fungicides for disease control. Black leaf streak can cause extensive defoliation. Yields are reduced, and fruit from affected plantations is prone to premature and uneven ripening. Because banana bunch weight is a function of the number of healthy leaves at flowering, it is critical to manage the crop and the disease so that an acceptable quantity and quality of fruit is harvested.
Black leaf streak disease symptoms on banana (Musa spp.) in Hawaii
Figure 1. The first symptom of black Sigatoka is minute chlorotic flecks on the undersurface of the third or fourth fully expanded leaf. The flecks develop into narrow rusty brown streaks and often have truncated ends and sides that are sharply limited by the leaf veins. On some cultivars, the streaks are less defined and have diffuse margins. During early stages, the streaks are visible only from the lower surfaces. |
Figure 2. Symptoms of black leaf streak disease on young banana suckers (above) differs from the symptoms on mature plants. On suckers, streaks rarely form; instead there are circular leaf spots ranging in color from black to brown to grayish, depending on the stage of plant and lesion development. |
|
Figure 4. On some varieties such as Cavendish types, leaves of young banana suckers naturally have maroon- colored blotches (above) that should not be mistaken for symptoms of black leaf streak disease. These blotches are naturally occurring on young plants and are not present on leaves of older plants. |
Figure 5. On mature banana leaves where triazole fungicides or translaminar fungicides are used to control black leaf streak, lesions appear first at the leaf midrib as the fungicide moves within tissues to distal parts of the leaves.
|
Figure 6. On mature banana leaves where triazole fungicides or translaminar fungicides are used to control black leaf streak, lesions appear first at the leaf midrib as the fungicide moves within tissues to distal parts of the leaves.
|
Figure 7. There is always a significant amount of yellowing of affected banana leaf tissues before they turn various shades of brown and gray. |
Figure 8. In areas of high rainfall, necrotic banana leaves turn very dark in color as the dead tissues becomes waterlogged. |
Figure 9. Hundreds of smaller black leaf streak lesions coalesce to form large, blighted ares on banana leaves.
|
Figure 10. Stagnant air and high humidity in the banana canopy favor the development of black leaf streak disease.
|
Figure 11. Ascospores of the pathogen, Mycosphaerella fijiensis, form in perithecia formed within the tan-colored centers of lesions.
|
Figure 12. The recommended IPM practice for managing the disease in Hawaii stipulates that this leaf should be removed from the plant, as it has more than 50% of the leaf area covered with black leaf streak disease. Large farms hire workers to move through field weekly, removing heavily diseased leaves from the plant and placing the upper leaf surface facing down upon the ground to minimize spore discharge into the atmosphere. |
Figure 13. Grasses and weeds around banana plants should be kept under control, otherwise if they are tall there is a lot of humidity created in the banana canopy, which favors infection and disease development. |
Figure 14. Even where fungicides are applied regularly at banana plantations, if the environment is very favorable for disease development plants may be largely defoliated before harvest, reducing bunch weight and fruit quality. |
4. Causal organism: biology and life cycle:
Life cycle of Mycosphaerella fijiensis in relation to banana and development of black leaf streak.
Figure 15. From: Agrios, George N. 2005. "Banana Leaf Spot or Sigatoka Disease", pp. 459-460 In: Plant Pathology (5th Edition). Elsevier Academic Press. |
The principal objective of black leaf streak disease management is to promote rapid and healthy plant growth in order to achieve a sufficient number of disease-free leaves by the time a banana plant flowers and begins to develop a bunch.
Weed control. Tall weeds (especially grasses) create high humidity in the plant canopy, which favors black leaf streak disease.
Choice of mist blower. Fan sizes for tractor-drawn mist blowers come in different sizes. Experience in Hawaii indicates that 31-inch-diameter fans provide superior disease control than 28- inch-diameter fans.
Use of spray adjuvants. It is important to use a "spreader sticker" such as Latron B to enhance fungicide coverage of leaves and adhesion to leaf surfaces.
Weekly scouting and disease records. Well-managed farms scout field weekly to estimate disease severity or "youngest leaf spotted." Thus provides a quantitative record how effective the disease control program is and also when to apply the next fungicide application, and can also help to detect the possible emergence of fungicide resistance in the pathogen population.
Chop up plants after harvest. A few seconds spent chopping up harvested plants (especially the leaves chopped off the fallen plants) can help to speed up the decomposition of the plants, which should reduce the viability of the fungal population.
Figure 16. One- or two-row planting geometries (with tractor roadways separating each two-row set) are most efficacious for managing black leaf streak disease in Hawaii. The objective is to achieve about 700 plants or production units per acre in this intensive style of farming. |
Figure 17. A worker thinning out the plant population (a practice referred to as "pruning"). This is done perhaps twice per year in a field to ensure efficient use of fertilizers and to optimize black leaf streak disease management by increasing air flow in the field and reducing relative humidity in the plant canopy. |
Figure 18. After pruning, chop up the downed plants if possible to speed up their decomposition. |
It is very important to maintain adequate level of banana plant nutrition in order to minimize the effects of black leaf streak disease. Undernourished plants are more susceptible to infection and also succumb more rapidly to disease. The objective is to have banana plants growing as quickly and possible, to "outgrow" the effects of the disease as symptoms "climb up" the plant. In Hawaii, banana growers try to produce plants with at least 10 healthy (disease-free) leaves at time of flowering, because after flowering there are no more leaves produced.
Crop logging is the monitoring of soil and banana tissue data over a period of time to help the grower make better decisions on the type, rate, and interval of fertilizer applications. Crop logging for banana consists of selecting banana leaf samples for tissue analysis. Here is the crop logging procedure for Hawaii: (1) Select a plant(s) that is(are) almost ready to flower. This could be a randomly or arbitrarily selected plant or a plant from a problematical part of a field; (2) Select the third leaf from the top of the plant for tissue analysis; (3) From the center of the leaf and ajacent to the leaf midrib, cut out rectangular pieces of leaf, about 2 " x 4" each; (4) Submit the tissue to the University of Hawaii at Manoa,College of Tropical Agriculture and Human Resource, Agricultural Diagnostic Service Center (UH-CTAHR ADSC). The advantages of crop logging include: (1) the practice provides a quantitative basis of decision making; (2) it allows early detection of problems; (3) one can verify suspected problems and interactions; (4) the practice can result in improved banana yield and quality; and (5) fertilizer use patterns are optimized.
Figure 19. Crop logging methodology. Tissue rectangles are removed from the 3rd banana leaf from the top of a plant just before flowering and submitted for analysis. After the analysis has been completed, the nutrient values obtained my be compared with the optimum ranges for bananas in Hawaii provided in the table below. |
Table 1. Recommended levels of elements in banana leaf tissue in Hawaii.
Element |
Symbol |
Range (suggested) |
NITROGEN |
N |
2.8 – 3.1% |
PHOSPHOROUS |
P |
0.18 – 0.20% |
POTASSIUM |
K |
3.2 – 3.5% |
CALCIUM |
Ca |
0.6 – 1.0% |
MAGNESIUM |
Mg |
0.3 – 0.6% |
SULFUR |
S |
0.22 – 0.25% |
IRON |
Fe |
50 – 100 ppm |
MANGANESE |
Mn |
30 – 100 ppm |
COPPER |
Cu |
10 – 15 ppm |
ZINC |
Zn |
25 – 40 ppm |
BORON |
B |
15 – 25 ppm |
Table 2. In addition to quantitative data, nutritional problems can diagnosed by observing the various symptoms associated with nutrient deficiencies of bananas.*
Deficient element
|
Symptoms
|
Notes
|
Nitrogen |
Generalized chlorosis (more yellowing on older leaves); rose-colored tints on petioles and leaf sheaths; stunting; rosetting; slender pseudostem; small petioles and leaves; reduced life span of leaves; notable reduction in yield. |
Banana is more sensitive to a lack of nitrogen than any other element; problem is compounded by dense stands of weeds or grass. |
Potassium |
Rapid yellowing of oldest leaves which then turn orange and dry up; leaves become tattered and fold downward; crumpled leaves; poorly filled bunch |
Responds well to potash applications |
Magnesium |
Marginal chlorosis of lowest leaves; violet-colored marbling of petioles; fruit may have defective flavor and not ship well. |
Magnesium sulphate can alleviate the symptoms. |
Calcium |
General dwarfing; reduced leaf length; reduced rate of leaf emission; leaves are undulated; tissue near midrib thickens, may turn reddish-brown |
Fields should be limes periodically; calcium nitrate can help to correct this deficiency. |
Iron |
General interveinal chlorosis of young leaves; retarded plant growth; small bunches |
Apply iron compounds to soil; foliar sprays of iron compounds can relieve symptoms temporarily. |
Zinc |
Rosetting and stunting; chlorotic, strap-shaped leaves; leaf chlorosis ion stripes or patches; abnormal bunch and hand characteristics |
Problem may be more severe in sandier areas. |
Sulphur |
Leaves are chlorotic and reduced in size with a thickening of secondary veins; undulating leaf edges; necrosis along edge of lower leaves |
Sulphate fertilizers can correct this problem (e.g., ammonium sulphate, potassium sulphate and magnesium sulphate) |
Boron |
Chlorotic streaking oriented perpendicular to and crossing the primary veins; leaf malformation; interveinal chlorosis |
Deficiency can develop over time in mature banana fields in Hawaii |
*Reference: Stover, R.H. 1972. Banana, plantain and abaca diseases. Commonwealth Mycological Institute, Kew, Surrey, England. 316
Element requirements for high-production banana farming in Hawaii*:
Element (pounds per acre per year)
Nitrogen (300-650)
Phosphorous (60-120)
Potassium (600-700)
*Expert farmers' recommendations for high-rainfall banana cultivation.
Fertilizers. Primary fertilizer sources for banana production in Hawaii: (1) "Banana Special" (13-3-37), general N-P-K fertilizer, about 200 lbs/acre/month; (2) Urea (sulfur-coated or poly-coated); (3) Potash, KSO or KCL; (4) Lime, dolomite (fields limed to pH 5.5 - 6.5 up to twice per year; (5) Borax, Solubor; (6) Zinc sulfate; (7) Sulfur
Figure 20 .13-3-37 ("Banana Special") is applied at about 0.35 pounds per "mat" (banana plant or production unit) per month.
Table 3. Fungicides registered for banana in Hawaii (2006). Products in bold font are effective for controlling banana black leaf streak in Hawaii. They are all commonly used, either alone (and in rotation) or in various tank-mix combinations. The triazole fungicides (febuconazole, tebuconazole) are reported to be the most effective. As systemic fungicides, the triazole fungicides provide the longest duration of disease mitigation after application, but also pose a risk for the development of fungicide resistance if they are overused.
COMMON NAME |
GENERAL TRADE NAMES |
copper hydroxide |
Kocide, Champion, Champ, Bac-Stop, Nu-Cop |
copper oxide |
Nordox |
tetraamine copper |
Liqui-cop |
mancozeb |
Dithane, Penncozeb, Manzate, Mankocide, Mancozeb, Lesco |
maneb |
Maneb, Manex |
fenbuconazole |
Enable |
azoxystrobin |
Abound |
tebuconazole |
Elite |
thiabendazole |
Decco Salt No. 19 |
brewer’s yeast extract |
Keyplex 350 OR |
K-bicarbonate |
Kaligreen |
hydrogen peroxide |
Oxidate, Storox |
fosetyl-Al |
Aliette |
phosphorous acid |
Fungi-phite |
K-phosphate |
Nutrol LC |
petroleum distillates (oils) |
Superior 70, Saf-T-Side, Sunspray Ultra-Fine, Biocover, Spray Oil, Year Round Horticultural Oil, Glacial Spray Fluid, Purespray Green |
*Table from Kawate, M. 2006. Banana Pesticide Update in: the Proceedings of the 37th Annual Hawaii Banana Industry Association Conference.
Fig. 21. Hand-held type of mist-blower for applying fungicides to banana plants. |
Figure 22. Tractor-mounted blower for applying fungicides to banana plants. |
Figure 23. Operating the mist blower in a banana field in Hawaii for black leaf streak control. Fungicides must be sprayed on a regular basis in high-rainfall areas for high-yielding banana cultivation. |
Choice of mist blower. Fan sizes for tractor-drawn mist blowers come in different sizes. Experience in Hawaii indicates that 31-inch-diameter fans provide superior disease control than 28- inch-diameter fans. Backpack mist blowers provide inferior coverage as compared with tractor-drawn mist blowers, machetes.
Use of spray adjuvants. It is important to use a "spreader sticker" such as Latron B to enhance fungicide coverage of leaves and adhesion to leaf surfaces.
7. Scouting and record keeping:
At large banana farms, scouts monitor for black leaf streak disease levels weekly. Then, fungicide spray applications are scheduled based upon the data collected. Shown below is an international disease rating scale used by some farmers. The idea is to scout fields regularly looking for plants of the same age (to be determined by the farmer, although plants pre-flowering are best) and gathering and recording disease information, usually on a sheet of paper on a clipboard. Some farmers simply collect data on "youngest leaf spotted" (youngest leaf showing symptoms, based on the idea that if young leaves become heavily diseased, then bunch yield and fruit quality will be very low.
High-production banana farms use the following tools and equipment to manage black leaf streak disease in Hawaii: Tractors, mist blowers (28" or 32" inch diameter fans), personnel protective equipment for spraying, pruning shovels or blades, de-trashing knives and poles, disease scouting sheets.
9. Managing or preventing fungicide resistance:
Fungicide resistance occurs when a product is no longer effective at controlling a disease due to a shift in the genetics of the target organism. Fungicide resistance is a consequence of (1) natural selection (increase in naturally resistant spores are favored frequent sprays) or (2) pathogen genetics (mutation, sexual recombination/reproduction). It can be a very serious problem where fungicide resistance develops in a plant pathogen population.
Types of Fungicide Resistance: (1) Single-step, major gene (one type of gene mutation is responsible; there is a sudden and marked loss of effectiveness; there are clear-cut sensitive and resistant populations; the developed resistance tends to be stable in the pathogen population); (2) Progressive, multiple genes (a number of genes are involved in a stepwise fashion; there is a gradual observed decline in control; there is a range of sensitivity in the pathogen population; the population reverts to more sensitive population with less intensive use of product).
Phenomena Associated with Fungicide Resistance: (1) Cross-resistance (the resistant population automatically and simultaneously becomes resistant to other products that have similar chemical relationships or mechanisms); (2) Multiple resistance (resistance occurs when a population develops separate mechanisms of resistance to more than one product; resistance arises from independent mutations selected from exposure to each of the products); (3) Negative cross-resistance (a rare condition in which change in resistance in one product results in sensitivity to another).
Resistance mechanisms: (1) Altered target site (target site for fungicidal actions experiences mutation which allows escape); (2) Metabolic and altered metabolic pathways (for example, demethylation inhibitors such as are present in the triazole fungicides febucionazole and tebuconazole.
In Hawaii, the primary risk of fungicide development in banana crops is where triazole fungicides (e.g., Enable and Elite) are used repeatedly.
Preventing Resistance Development in Fungi:
- Do not use product in isolation: Apply the product(s) as: (1) a mixture with one or more different fungicides; or (2) as a component in a fungicide rotation. Do not alternate or tank mix with fungicides to which resistance has already developed in your population.
Examples of tank mixtures:
Dithane + Oil
Abound + Enable or Elite (triazoles)
Dithane + (triazole)
All of the above plus Latron 1956 which “dries hard”
Manex II + Superior 70 oil
Example of block spraying program rotation. This program was developed by the Hawaii banana industry for prudent use of the effective triazole fungicides, Elite or Enable.
Jan 16 – Mar 1 non-triazole (Dithane, Oil, Abound)
Mar 2 – May 31 triazole (Enable, Elite)
Jun 1 – Sep 30 non-triazole (Dithane, Oil, Abound)
Oct 1 – Jan 15 triazole (Enable, Elite)
- Apply only when necessary (or just before) and restrict application numbers.
Disease monitoring (Example: DITHANE M-45): “DITHANE M-45 fungicide is a broad-spectrum, protectant fungicide. If not applied on a routine protectant spray schedule, crop should be scouted on a weekly basis. Fungicide application should be made at the recommended label use rate and spray schedule, at first sign of disease, report of disease in the area, or during environmental conditions favorable for disease development.”
Fungicide Label Directions for ABOUND (azoxystrobin) resistance management : “Do not apply more than 2 sequential sprays of ABOUND Flowable before alternating with a fungicide that has a different mode of action. Do not make more than 8 applications of ABOUND Flowable or other stroliburin fungicides per acre per year.”
Fungicide Label Directions: ENABLE 2F resistance management: “Do not apply more than 8 times (0.72 lbs. Active) per acre per year.”
Fungicide Label Directions: ELITE Resistance Management: There are no specific recommendations printed on the label, but please follow same instructions as for ENABLE 2F, as both are in the same class of fungicides (triazoles).
- Maintain recommended dose:
Use enough water to get thorough coverage. Set spray equipment to get good coverage (amount, rate of travel through field). Use of LATRON surfactant to spray solutions will improve performance. A typical tank mixture and spray rate for controlling black leaf streak disease in Hawaii using contact ("protectant"), surface-acting fungicides is as follows. One could also add a triazole fungicide at the recommended rate:
12 gallon per acre mix consisting of the following:
1- Manzate flowable - 2 qts. /acre
2- Superior 70 - 1 gallon/acre
3- Latron (spreader/sticker) - 3 oz./acre- Minimize the eradicant use of systemic fungicides: "Be proactive"
- Integrate all available control mechanisms (IPM):